Skip to main content

Compare
Procardia XL vs. Catapres-TTS

Head-to-head comparisons of medication uses, side effects, warnings, and more.

Key takeaways

Nifedipine (Procardia XL) and clonidine (Catapres, Nexiclon XR) are both used to treat high blood pressure, but they work in different ways and have different uses. Nifedipine is a calcium channel blocker that relaxes blood vessels to lower blood pressure and treat chest pain. It comes in extended-release and immediate-release forms, with the extended-release form being more commonly prescribed. Clonidine, on the other hand, is an alpha agonist that works in the brain to lower stress hormones, slowing your heart rate and relaxing blood vessels. It is available as a tablet and a patch. Clonidine is not usually a first-choice treatment for high blood pressure because it can cause "rebound hypertension" if stopped suddenly and is not recommended for older adults due to the risk of falls. Nifedipine is available in a lower-cost generic form, as are most forms of clonidine. Nexiclon XR (a form of Clonidine) is only available as a brand-name product. Common side effects of nifedipine include swelling in the legs and dizziness, while clonidine can cause dry mouth, drowsiness, and skin reactions with the patch.

Nifedipine ER

(Procardia XL)

Get free coupons

Clonidine

 

Get free coupons

Summary for Procardia XL

Prescription only

Nifedipine (Procardia, Procardia XL) is a calcium channel blocker (CCB). It's used to treat certain heart conditions, such as chest pain (angina) and high blood pressure in adults. It mainly works by relaxing your blood vessels, making it easier for blood to flow. Nifedipine is available as an extended-release pill (ER) that's taken by mouth once daily, and a immediate-release pill (IR) that's taken three times a day. Keep in mind the nifedipine IR is rarely prescribed. Some side effects of nifedipine include swelling in the legs, dizziness, tiredness, and headache.

Indications for Procardia XL

  • Chest pain (angina)
  • High blood pressure (hypertension) - extended-release tablets only

Pros and Cons for Procardia XL

Pros

  • Lowers risk of heart attack and stroke in people with high blood pressure
  • Can take it alone or with other medications to help with blood pressure or chest pain
  • Calcium channel blockers, such as nifedipine ER (Procardia XL), work especially well for Black people to lower blood pressure
  • The extended-release tablets are taken once daily
  • Available as a lower-cost, generic form

Cons

  • Often causes swelling in the legs and feet
  • Not a good choice if you have heart failure because of risk for swelling
  • If you have severe heart disease, it can raise your risk of having a heart attack or worsening chest pain
  • The immediate-release capsule needs to be taken 3 to 4 times a day

Common Side Effects for Procardia XL

Extended-release tablets:

  • Swelling (edema) in the legs, feet, or hands (10-30%)
  • Headache (16%)
  • Fatigue (6%)
  • Dizziness (4%)

Immediate-release capsules:

  • Dizziness or lightheadedness (27%)
  • Flushing (25%)
  • Headache (23%)
  • Weakness (12%)
  • Nausea (11%)
  • Swelling (10%)

Warnings for Procardia XL

  • Low blood pressure
  • Risk of worsening chest pain or heart attack
  • Risk of heart failure
  • Swelling in legs and feet
  • Stomach or intestinal injury (extended-release form only)

Summary for Catapres-TTS

Prescription only

Clonidine is a prescription medication that can be used to treat high blood pressure. It comes in 3 forms: topical patch, immediate-release tablet, and extended-release tablet. Clonidine usually isn't a first-choice option to treat high blood pressure because it can cause "rebound hypertension" (sudden rise in blood pressure) when the medication is suddenly stopped. Clonidine also isn't recommended for older adults since it can raise the risk for falls.

Indications for Catapres-TTS

  • High blood pressure

Pros and Cons for Catapres-TTS

Pros

  • Can be take along with other other blood pressure medications to help manage blood pressure
  • Available in a once-weekly patch for people who can't take medicine by mouth
  • Immediate-release tablets and patches available as lower-cost generics

Cons

  • Taking it with alcohol can cause excessive sleepiness
  • Can raise the risk for falls in older adults
  • Can cause dangerously high blood pressure if stopped too suddenly or if a dose is missed

Common Side Effects for Catapres-TTS

The following side effects are those reported with immediate-release clonidine:

  • Dry mouth (40%)
  • Drowsiness (33%)
  • Dizziness (16%)
  • Constipation (10%)
  • Feeling low energy (10%)

Please note: Side effects for Nexiclon XR are similar to that of immediate-release clonidine


The following side effects are those reported with clonidine patch:

  • Itchy rash (26%)
  • Dry mouth (25%)
  • Drowsiness (12%)
  • Blisters (7%)
  • Feeling tired (6%)
  • Headache (5%)
  • Skin becomes darker (5%)

Warnings for Catapres-TTS

  • Withdrawal
  • Sleepiness and dizziness
  • Heart problem
  • Skin reactions (clonidine patches)

Prices with our coupons for Procardia XL vs. Catapres-TTS

Price Card Drug Icon
Nifedipine ER (Procardia XL)30 tablets / 30mg
$17.87$19.65
Get free coupons
More Information
Price Card Drug Icon
Clonidine30 tablets / 0.1mg
$2.55$2.55
Get free coupons
More Information

Browse medications by letter

Show All

Browse prescription and over-the-counter medications from A to Z, compare drug prices, and start saving.